Comparing Macbook Air, Dell XPS, and Dell Alienware
- EN
- JA
Table of Contents
Deciding on a New Laptop
About three months ago, I parted ways with my Samsung S1 Tab. To be honest, I couldn’t quite get the hang of using it effectively, so I decided to pass it on and look for a new laptop for work.
The Samsung S1 Tab was high-performance, had a beautiful display, and great battery life. It was useful for work, but being accustomed to PCs, I found the multi-window behavior unfamiliar and typing on a touchscreen cumbersome.
However, I believe the Samsung S1 Tab had the potential to do everything without needing a PC if used effectively.
Choosing a PC for Everyday Use and Video Editing
For my next PC, I decided to prioritize ease of use. But what does "ease of use" mean? I took a moment to think about what I really wanted.
First, having an English keyboard layout was a must. I’m used to using PCs with English layouts, so switching to a Japanese layout would feel very inconvenient.
Next, I wanted a device that I could easily use to browse news and blogs. I imagined myself reading news and blogs on a weekend morning with a warm cup of tea (I’m not a coffee fan), so I wanted something I could use casually and seamlessly. I also desired a design that would blend into my lifestyle.
Additionally, I wanted a PC that could handle intermediate-level software for editing family trip videos and photos, with a large, vibrant display. Although I’m an amateur at video and photo editing, I love trying new things as soon as I learn about them, so this was non-negotiable.
Lastly, it would be nice to play PC games occasionally. It doesn’t have to be high-quality, but I wanted to be able to play games on Steam Remote or low-spec games.
With these criteria in mind, I started my search for a PC.
After Three Months of Deliberation
However, once I started looking, I found it difficult to find a PC that met all my criteria.
In Japan, PCs with English layouts are not widely available, so finding one with the right budget, specs, and design was challenging.
I debated whether I needed a GPU, and if so, whether it should be the latest Geforce model.
Moreover, with recent PCs and CPUs featuring AI models, 2-in-1 devices with excellent portability, and the current exchange rate making it a good time to buy during sales, I found myself distracted by various temptations.
At times, I even considered importing directly from the US or buying two devices.
For three months, I searched for a PC almost daily.
Narrowing Down to Three Models
As time passed and I couldn’t make a decision, with Black Friday approaching, I felt it would be a waste to miss out on the big sale. So, I worked hard to select candidate laptops.
The three models I considered were:
-
Apple Macbook Air 15-inch: Chosen for its aspirational design and sufficient specs. I owned a Macbook Pro about ten years ago, so I thought it might be a good time to return to it.
-
Dell XPS 15-inch with GPU: I love using the XPS 13 for work, so I have a good idea of its capabilities and limitations. The design isn’t bad either.
-
Dell Alienware 16-inch: It has a cool design, a large, vibrant screen, and a Geforce GPU, making it suitable for gaming. The design is particularly appealing.
I then compared the following points in detail:
-
Ease of Use:
-
Apple Macbook Air 15-inch: Weighs 1.51 KG, making it highly portable. The battery life is long enough to use it anywhere, anytime.
-
Dell XPS 15-inch: Weighs 1.86 KG, which might be a bit heavy for carrying around, but should be fine for moving around the house.
-
Dell Alienware 16-inch: Weighs 2.9 KG, about the same as a Roomba i3. I’m concerned about carrying it around easily.
-
-
Display Quality:
-
Apple Macbook Air 15-inch: The Liquid Retina display is stunning, as expected from a creator-favorite device.
-
Dell XPS 15-inch: With FHD+ 1920x1200 resolution and 500 nits brightness, it’s not extremely high resolution, but brighter than the average laptop or smartphone display.
-
Dell Alienware 16-inch: Features a 16.0-inch QHD+ 2560x1600 display with 240Hz, 100% sRGB, 3ms response time, Advanced Optimus, ComfortView Plus, and NVIDIA G-SYNC. It seems perfect for gaming and movies.
-
-
Specs for Video Editing and Gaming:
-
Apple Macbook Air 15-inch: Equipped with the M3 chip, suitable for intermediate video editing and light gaming. The main issue is the limited availability of Mac-compatible games.
-
Dell XPS 15-inch: Features an Intel Core i7 13th Gen, 16GB RAM, and Intel GPU A370M GDDR6 4GB. Suitable for intermediate video editing and light gaming. The difference in specs compared to the M3 might be due to the difference between integrated and dedicated GPUs.
-
Dell Alienware 16-inch: With a Core™ Ultra 7 processor 155H and NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4050 6GB GDDR6, it seems capable of handling 3D and the latest games, as well as 4K video editing.
-
-
Noise and Heat:
-
Apple Macbook Air 15-inch: No fan, so likely no noise. However, without a fan, the laptop might get hot under heavy load, which is a concern.
-
Dell XPS 15-inch: Has a fan, so there will be some noise, but it’s manageable. I expect it to be similar to the XPS 13.
-
Dell Alienware 16-inch: The high-performance GPU might cause fan noise, but the system is designed to manage heat, so it shouldn’t be too loud.
-
-
Design:
-
Apple Macbook Air 15-inch: Iconic design, often seen in cafes, which is appealing.
-
Dell XPS 15-inch: Business-oriented design, but refined, as it competes with Macbook.
-
Dell Alienware 16-inch: Very cool design, with glowing elements and a stylish logo.
-
-
Customization:
-
Apple Macbook Air 15-inch: Unix-based, allowing some customization, but it’s designed for creators, so customization feels like a workaround. SSD and RAM can’t be upgraded, making customization costly.
-
Dell XPS 15-inch: Initially runs Windows, but based on my experience with the XPS 13, Linux installation should be possible. NVME M2 SSD and RAM can be replaced, allowing for significant customization.
-
Dell Alienware 16-inch: Limited information, but Linux installation seems possible. However, I’m unsure if it’s suitable to use a gaming PC primarily with Linux.
-
The Final Decision
After reviewing various sites and YouTuber opinions, I ultimately chose the Dell XPS 15-inch.
I was tempted by the Apple Macbook Air 15-inch, but the customization and versatility of Linux gave the XPS 15 an edge. Its weaknesses are the slightly weaker GPU and lower display resolution compared to the other two models.
However, I have another machine with a Geforce GPU, so I can cover that aspect, and I can use an external display for high-quality work, addressing my concerns.
If I weren’t in the IT field, I might have chosen the M3 Macbook Air for its design and creator-friendly features.
The Alienware 16-inch was less appealing due to its weight and heat issues.
Expected Arrival This Month
So, I’ve purchased the XPS 15 and am eagerly awaiting its arrival. Can’t wait for it to get here!